First United Brethren Church, also known as Otterbein Methodist Church, is a historic building located in Toledo, Iowa, United States.

Built in 1946, this building replaced an 1886 sanctuary that was destroyed in a fire in 1943.

The original church had been associated with Leander Clark College, which had been operated by the Church of the United Brethren in Christ, until its merger with Coe College in 1919.

The congregation consolidated into the church buildings on South Broadway in August 2015.

Hobart Historic Restoration of Cedar Rapids bought this building and plans to converting it into 15 apartments.