The church building at 18th and Central was constructed in 1890 and added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1975.

The Reverend W. W. Baldwin, a circuit rider from Colorado, led the first Methodist church services in Cheyenne on September 29, 1867 in City Hall.

[3] Two years later the Society bought two lots at 18th and Central Avenues from the Union Pacific for $1.00 and lumber for a white frame church was ordered from Chicago.

In 1874 Black members withdrew from the congregation and built an African Methodist Episcopal Church four blocks west.

[2] On March 5, 1876, the Methodist minister Reverend Warren married Wild Bill Hickok and Agnes Thatcher Lake, a 50-year-old circus proprietor at a nearby residence.