[1] McCaffrey was the co-head football coach at Fordham University with Frank Gargan for one season, in 1917, and compiled a record of 7–2.
[4] A 5'8",[5] 165-pound end, he earned the nickname "Bull" for his aggressive playing style.
[4] He was Fordham's first-ever All-America selection when in 1909, his junior season, when Walter Camp chose him as one of the college football's premier players.
He was the chief of the dental clinic at Fordham Hospital and an associate professor at Columbia University.
This biographical article relating to a college football coach first appointed in the 1910s is a stub.