[1] The four-track collection includes cover versions of songs by Lana Del Rey, Violent Femmes, Cher, and Johnny Cash.

The final two tracks are renditions of Cher's "Believe" and "Jackson", a collaboration featuring country singer Orville Peck.

[6] Tyler Maas of the Milwaukee Record said Trixie Mattel's version of "Video Games" is "excellent and true-to-album".

[7] Tony Madden of Traklife Music commented that "the original songs vary greatly in nearly every respect; each one hails from a different decade, genre and artist.

But Mattel brings the tracks together as cohesively as ever with a smooth tenor voice and an array of acoustic instruments", calling the EP "a testament to her versatility".