It was under the manager of Ronald Koeman that gave Zeefuik first team chance following the absence of Arouna Koné and was impressed with his abilities with his scoring and stay on the ball.
[2] Zeefuik made his professional debut for PSV on March 31, 2007 in a league match against NAC Breda, where he came on as a substitute for Jason Culina in the 65th minute, which both side drew 1-1.
[4] He was previously linked with a move to Premier League side Liverpool before signing a contract with PSV.
[5] Zeefuik made his first appearance of the 2007-08 season, where he came on as a substitute for Jonathan Reis in the 73rd minute, in a 1-0 loss against Ajax in the Johan Cruijff Schaal.
[7] With his contract expiring at the end of the 2010-11 season, Zeefuik announced his decision to leave the club and to prove PSV wrong that they didn't use him regularly.
[10] After fighting his way to the first team, despite tearing his anterior cruciate ligament at the start of the season, Zeefuik was on the verge of signing a contract with PSV.
[29] Zeefuik then scored two braces in two games against Emmen[30] and [31] He had six more goals in the 2009-10 season against Telstar,[32] Go Ahead Eagles,[33] BV Veendam,[34] AGOVV[35] and Volendam.
[50] Four days later on 26 September 2012, Zeefuik scored again in the second round of KNVB Bekker and providing assist, in a 2-1 win over GVVV.
[52] After regaining his fitness with a use of individual training program,[53] Zeefuik made his first team return, where he played 90 minutes, in a 0-0 draw against VVV-Venlo on 15 December 2012.
[57] Zeefuik made his return to the first team against Heracles Almelo, but was involved in a dispute with teammate Leandro Bacuna, whether who should take it.
[70][71] After rejecting a move to Cambuur, Zeefuik was involved in the first team, but was occasionally used when he mostly on the substitute bench in the second half of the season, as he made fourteen appearances and scoring three times.
[73] However, Zeefuik failed his medical after Willem II found out his histories of groin injury despite the deal was agreed.
[84] At the expiry of his loan deal he returned to FC Groningen, rumors of a permanent transfer to Hearts were circulated in the press but did not come to fruition.
[85] Rumours once again circulated that he would resign for Heart of Midlothian but following their recruitment of Spanish striker Juanma no move materialised.
[76][87] Zeefuik made his Balikesirspor debut, in the opening game of the season, in a 0–0 draw against Gaziantep BB, before coming off in the 66th minute.
[88] Despite Zeefuik scoring 12 goals throughout the season, Balikesirspor's chairman announced at the end of the campaign that he had not met expectations and that the club would listen to offers for him in the market.
[89] In November 2020, Zeefuik announced his retirement from football aged 30, due to mental health related issues.
Though born in Amsterdam, Netherlands, Zeefuik was eligible to play for Suriname and was called up in late-December, but Groningen rejected the call-up.