[3] The team's starting center as a senior, Schollenberger was named Temple's most valuable lineman.

[2] He also played baseball at the school and was prominent in social affairs, being a member of the Blue Key Honor Society and an officer for the Theta Upsilon Omega fraternity.

[4][5] He was often offered better coaching positions at other schools but declined them due to wanting to stay at Laurel; The Daily Times noted that he was so well-known that teams in the National Football League sometimes asked of his opinions.

[8] He was named the Delaware Coach of the Year in 1957, after having led Laurel to an undefeated 7–0 record while outscoring opposition 222–12.

[11][12] A book on his life was written by his son, and an athletic training facility in Laurel was built and named in his honor in 1985.