During the 1913–14 season, Sheffield United were looking to sign a new captain to change their fortunes, having struggled in both the league and cup since the retirement of Ernest Needham.

[9] In the semi-final of the 1914–15 FA Cup, Utley's goal in the 2–1 victory over Bolton Wanderers was described as "the best of his career",[10] as he dribbled the ball 60 yards before scoring.

Utley, as captain, worked hard and decisively throughout the game, breaking up many Chelsea attacks and providing many passes to the United forwards.

The board had been willing to make an exception for Utley, citing his importance to the team and wishing to ensure he stayed with the club.

[8] This extraordinary move by the club caused unrest in the dressing room and nine of the first team signed a letter to the United directors, written by Billy Gillespie, complaining that this preferential treatment was unfair.

[8] The game went ahead a few days later without Utley, although ironically Billy Gillespie scored twice in a 3–1 win in front of over 36,000 spectators.

They stipulated that testimonials could only be played after an agreed period of time stated within a players contract, or upon their career being unexpectedly cut short.

[8] During the later part of his football career he authored articles for boys magazines including:[16] Utley died in January 1966.