She went on to win her second title in Crossfire Wrestling, where she won the CW Women's Championship in a triple-threat match against Beautiful Beaa and Jody Threat.

Due to this impressive two month long winning streak, Shaw earned an opportunity to face Undisputed British Women's Champion Zoe Lucas at RevPro New Year's Revolution but was unsuccessful in her first attempt.

Despite her shortcomings, Shaw earned another opportunity for the championship after winning a #1 contenders four way on January 10, 2020, that also involved Debbie Keitel, Shanna, and Kasey Owens.

After failing to win the tournament, Shaw began defending the British Women's Championship regularly again as she defeated the likes of Hyan (twice), Mariah May, and Lizzy Evo.

Shaw made her Progress Wrestling debut at Chapter 93: Cheer Up Juice, in a losing effort against Dani Luna in a four way which also included Jody Threat and Yuu.

After Kanji was forced to relinquish the Progress World Women's Championship, it was announced Gisele Shaw, Alexxis Falcon and Mercedez Blaze would compete for the vacant title at Chapter 117: Making Diamonds on August 14, 2021.

Following this, Shaw began defending the title successfully against the likes of Laura Di Matteo, Rhio, Skye Smitson, Debbie Keitel, and Alexxis Falcon (twice).

Five months later, Shaw represented Destiny World Wrestling on August 25 at One Night Only: Bad Intentions, competing for the Impact Knockouts Championship held by Tessa Blanchard.

On the February 10, episode of Before the Impact!, Shaw made her official debut confronting fellow newcomer Lady Frost after her match with Alisha Edwards.

[5] Since June, Shaw has a short-lived alliances with the teams of The Influence (Madison Rayne and Tenille Dashwood)[6] and later with VXT (Chelsea Green and Purrazzo).

On January 13, 2024, at Hard to Kill, Shaw won an Ultimate X match to become the #1 contender for the newly renamed TNA Knockouts World Championship.

[15] After taking time off to recover from an injury, a series of vignettes featuring Gail Kim mentoring Shaw were aired, teasing a face turn.

[16] On May June 6, 2024 edition of TNA IMpact, Gisele Shaw made her return as a face, defeating Shazza McKenzie in her first match back.

[22] On September 11, 2024, it was announced that Gissle Shaw will face the longest reigning ROH Women's World Champion Athena for the title on the second night of Maple Leaf Pro Wrestling's (MLP) event Forged in Excellence on October 20.