1, while a slightly altered version appeared on the band's third studio album Siren Song of the Counter Culture later that year.

The accompanying music video has the band perform in a crowded subway car, while other people travel throughout the city of Chicago vandalizing and defacing billboards and posters, with the intention of raising social and political awareness.

[a][3] This deal was criticized by some fans, who felt that a major record label would hinder the band's creative process and negatively impact their music.

[10] Commercially, "Give It All" became the first Rise Against song to reach the Billboard Modern Rock Tracks chart, peaking at number thirty-seven on January 1, 2005.

[11] Upon the release of Siren Song of the Counter Culture, "Give It All" received almost no coverage from music critics who reviewed the album,[12] aside from Justin Donnelly of Blistering, who described the piece as "a little generic and forgettable".

[13] Despite the lack of coverage, it has become one of the band's most widely recognized songs, and John J. Moser of The Morning Call credits it as Rise Against's breakthrough single.

[15] Simultaneously, other passengers leave the car and travel throughout the city at night, vandalizing and defacing billboards and posters with the intention of raising social and political awareness.