The side took part in one edition of the Papua New Guinea National Soccer League, the 2015–16 season, and finished bottom of the Northern Conference after losing all ten of their matches.

[1] In late 2015, it was revealed that a club from Goroka would be taking part in an expanded edition of the Papua New Guinea National Soccer League.

[5] In an attempt to boost their fortunes, Agunam secured the signings of two former Welgris Highlanders players Marshall Lori and Japheth Olow, as well as Lae City Dwellers' midfielder Michael Saun ahead of the second half of the season.

[2] However, the side continued to struggle,[6] losing all ten of their matches, with their fate sealed on the final day after a 3–0 defeat to Morobe FC.

[7] Ahead of the 2019 season, Agunam claimed she believed that the region had enough talent to justify a return to the NSL.