He won his first of ten mixed provincial titles in 1986, when he and his team of Anne-Marie Vautour, brother Terry and Denise Lavigne defeated Gary Mitchell in the New Brunswick final.

[2] He won another mixed title in 1989, with a new team of Nancy Reid, Rick Perron and Lynn MacKenzie, defeating Bruce Forster in the provincial final.

[11] A few months later, Odishaw won the provincial mixed title again, this time with Denise Bowser throwing third, and Perron's wife Leanne at lead.

[13] The team represented the province at the 2020 Canadian Mixed Curling Championship (played in November 2019), where they made it to the final before losing to Quebec's Jean-Sébastien Roy rink.

Odishaw won another provincial mixed title in 2022 with teammates Shaelyn Park, Samuel Forestell and Krista Flanagan, defeating Charlie Sullivan in the final.

Odishaw won his second provincial title in 1996 as the third for Mike Kennedy, when the team beat Saskatchewan-transplant Mark Dacey twice in the double knockout New Brunswick championship final.

When two-time World Champion Russ Howard moved to Moncton in 1998, Odishaw was asked to join him on a five-player rotation with the goal of winning that season's provincial championship.

It wasn't quite the cakewalk expected for a former World champion, as the team did lose a few games, going 29–3 during playdown play, and barely beat Blanchard 6–5 for the Tankard.

[18] At the Brier in 1999, with Odishaw throwing lead rocks, they made the playoffs, but lost to Saskatchewan's Gerald Shymko rink in the 3 vs. 4 game.

They repeated as provincial champions in 2003, defeating Odishaw's brother Terry in the New Brunswick final, capping off a second straight unbeaten Tankard run.

[22] This time, at the 2004 Nokia Brier, the rink missed the playoffs after losing in a tiebreaker game to British Columbia's Jay Peachey.