He subsequently had starring roles on the soap opera Pacific Palisades (also 1997), and portrayed a record executive in the Canadian series Big Sound from 2001 to 2002.

[2] Between 1972 and 1973, he starred as Danny Zuko in the Broadway production of Grease, reprising the role for the show's residency in Chicago, alongside Marilu Henner.

[8] Between 1996 and 1997, Evigan guest-starred as Dr. Dan Hathaway on the soap opera Melrose Place,[9] followed by a main role on Pacific Palisades, in which he portrayed one of several friends who relocate from the Midwest to California.

[10] In 2001, he starred in the psychological thriller film Spirit opposite Elisabeth Moss, playing the father of a teenage girl who believes their home is haunted.

[11] He reunited with director Joey Travolta, appearing in his family drama Arizona Summer (2004),[10] followed by a supporting part in River's End (2005).

[9] He had a guest-starring role on the network crime series Bones in 2017,[9] followed by a multi-episode character arc as Jim Harvey on General Hospital in 2018.