During the 2003 season, Sutton helped the Montreal Impact become the USL squad with the lowest goals allowed total and won the Goalkeeper of the Year honor.

Sutton was the team's starting goalkeeper until he received a head concussion during CONCACAF Gold Cup training with Canada in June.

Since a team doctor did not accompany the Canadian squad, he was cleared by a local physician and later suffered from post-concussion syndrome as a result, ruling him out of play for the rest of the year.

[1] Sutton was dropped for the 2008 season opener in favour of draft pick Brian Edwards, but made his return against D.C. United at RFK Stadium in Toronto's second game.

[3] On April 27, 2010, Sutton officially debuted for New York in a 2–1 victory over Philadelphia Union in a 2010 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup qualification match.

Sutton began the 2011 Major League Soccer season as New York's starting goalkeeper helping the club to a 1–0 victory over Seattle Sounders FC on March 19, 2011.

[5] After the signing of German goalkeeper Frank Rost, Sutton was loaned out to Canadian North American Soccer League team Montreal Impact on July 16, 2011.