In addition, "Guilty" won a Grammy Award in the category Best Pop Vocal Performance, Duo or Group.

The song also appeared on the 2001 Bee Gees compilation, Their Greatest Hits: The Record.

[citation needed] Record World said that "Barbra's vocal glistens like an early morning dewdrop while Barry adorns with plush harmonies"[6] In 2023, American Songwriter and The Guardian both named "Guilty" as Streisand's second-greatest song.

Australian band Human Nature, released a cover version of the song as the second single from their album Walk the Tightrope.

Gibb performs on guitar, Blue Weaver on keyboard and Albhy Galuten on synthesizer.