The distinctive three story main body and interior design are credited to John H. Lothrop, a Hamilton College trustee.

The tower of the eastern façade of the building is topped by a white, octagonal cupola.

The quill weathervane[2] atop the cupola is representative of Hamilton College's commitment to teaching students to write effectively.

Until 1872 the college library was housed in increasing portions of the top floor the chapel.

In 1877 the three faced clock still in evidence today was donated by John Wanamaker, of Philadelphia.