Now unwanted by Arsenal, Storer was signed by Liverpool's manager John McKenna and William Barclay in December 1895.

He kept the goalkeeping shirt for the remaining 11 games conceding just 8 goals as Liverpool regained their spot back in the top tier of English football.

Storer then had a long run in the first team, missing just 7 of the Reds' 87 fixtures, he was eventually replaced by the versatile Matt McQueen for two matches and then William Perkins for the final five games of the 1898–99 season.

Storer then became Perkins' understudy and apart from an 11 match spell in 1899 he never played for the club again although he didn't leave until 1901.

He was a right-handed batsman and played 10 innings in 6 first-class matches, with a top score of 35 and an average of 10.22.