From the late 19th century and continuing through the early 1930s, Haskell's football program regularly scheduled games against regional and national powers and became known as the "Powerhouse of the West".

After Kennedy departed, the success continued as the 1919 team compiled an 8–1–1 record, including victories over Oklahoma A&M and Kansas State.

Prominent players on Hanley's teams included backs John Levi and Mayes McLain.

In the early 1930s, the Bureau of Indian Affairs eliminated junior college courses and reduced the school's emphasis on intercollegiate athletics.

After the 1938 season, Haskell dropped intercollegiate football altogether until 1946, when the program was revived, with the schedule mostly consisting of military academys, forts, and junior colleges.