In her freshman season (2013–14), she was chosen as a Hockey East Pro Ambitions All-Rookie Forward,[3] as well as the Rookie of the Month for February 2014.

In her final season (2016–17), Scamurra scored 8 goals and an impressive 23 assists, despite losing Kendall Coyne as a linemate.

The Buffalo Beauts defeated the Boston Pride and won the Isobel Cup as 2016-17 NWHL champions.

[11] The Beauts again reached the NWHL finals, achieving this feat for the third consecutive season, before ultimately losing in overtime to the Minnesota Whitecaps.

[16] On December 30, 2024, she, alongside Savannah Harmon, was traded to the Toronto Sceptres in exchange for Jocelyne Larocque and Victoria Bach.

[20][21] In the Olympics, Scamurra scored a pivotal goal to put Team USA up 3-0 in the semi-final game against Finland.