Healthcare reform in the United States

[24] In March 2010, billionaire Warren Buffett commented that the high costs paid by U.S. companies for their employees' health care put them at a competitive disadvantage.

[25] Further, an estimated 77 million Baby Boomers are reaching retirement age, which combined with significant annual increases in healthcare costs per person will place enormous budgetary strain on U.S. state and federal governments, particularly through Medicare and Medicaid spending (Medicaid provides long-term care for the elderly poor).

[28] Even for those who are employed, the private insurance in the US varies greatly in its coverage; one study by the Commonwealth Fund published in Health Affairs estimated that 16 million U.S. adults were underinsured in 2003.

The underinsured were significantly more likely than those with adequate insurance to forgo health care, report financial stress because of medical bills, and experience coverage gaps for such items as prescription drugs.

[29] However, a study published by the Kaiser Family Foundation in 2008 found that the typical large employer preferred provider organization (PPO) plan in 2007 was more generous than either Medicare or the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program Standard Option.

Other studies, just as those examining the randomized distribution of Medicaid insurance to low-income people in Oregon in 2008, found no change in death rate.

This relates to moral arguments for health care reform, framing healthcare as a social good, one that is fundamentally immoral to deny to people based on economic status.

[37] The motivation behind healthcare reform in response to the medical-industrial complex also stems from issues of social inequity, promotion of medicine over preventative care.

[39] Likewise, critiques of insurance markets being conducted under a capitalistic, free-market model also include that medical solutions, as opposed to preventative healthcare measures, are promoted to maintain this medical-industrial complex.

In a research study which was conducted comparing the effects of the ACA before and after it was fully implemented in 2014, it was discovered that racial and ethnic minorities benefited more than whites with many gaining insurance coverage which they lacked before allowing for many to seek treatment improving their overall health.

[41][42][43] In December 2011 the outgoing administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Donald Berwick, asserted that 20% to 30% of health care spending is waste.

[51] However, conservative commentator David Gratzer and the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, have both criticized the WHO's comparison method for being biased; the WHO study marked down countries for having private or fee-paying health treatment and rated countries by comparison to their expected health care performance, rather than objectively comparing quality of care.

In addition, the Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act of 2010 contained provisions which allows the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to undertake pilot projects which, if they are successful could be implemented in future.

A number of proposals have been made for a universal single-payer healthcare system in the United States, most recently the Medicare for All Act, but none have achieved more political support than 20% congressional co-sponsorship.

[81] An analysis of a single-payer bill by the Physicians for a National Health Program estimated the immediate savings at $350 billion per year.

[82] The Commonwealth Fund believes that, if the United States adopted a universal health care system, the mortality rate would improve and the country would save approximately $570 billion a year.

[84][85][86] On June 1, 2017, in light of the recent Trump administration's efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act, California Democratic Senator Ricardo Lara proposed a bill to establish single-payer healthcare within the state of California (SB 562), calling on fellow senators to act quickly in defense of healthcare.

[88] In the past, California has struggled to maintain healthcare effectiveness, due in part to its unstable budget and complex regulations.

The Congressional Budget Office estimated it would reduce the United States public debt by $104 billion over 10 years.

The current system encourages medical interventions such as surgeries and prescribed medicines (all of which carry some risk for the patient but increase revenues for the medical care industry) and does not reward other activities such as encouraging behavioral changes such as modifying dietary habits and quitting smoking, or follow-ups regarding prescribed regimes which could have better outcomes for the patient at a lower cost.

Projects at CMS are examining the possibility of rewarding health care providers through a process known as "bundled payments"[93] by which local doctors and hospitals in an area would be paid not on a fee for service basis but on a capitation system linked to outcomes.

The Court ruled that implementing taxes in order to pay for health insurance for all citizens was an unconstitutional exercise of Congress's power under Article I.

State and federal initiatives, primarily sponsored CMMI (Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation) a division of CMS, seek to address basic social needs within the context of the healthcare delivery system.

[96] The model was officially implemented in 2017 and will be evaluated for its ability to affect cost of healthcare spending and reduce inpatient/outpatient utilization in 2022.

Applying this tool in the AHC model will help CMS evaluate the impact of local partnerships between healthcare providers and community organizations in advancing the aims of addressing the cost and quality of health care across all settings.

[100] without access to reliable, affordable, and convenient transportation, patients miss appointments and end up costing clinics money.

According to a cross-study analysis, missed appointments and care delays cost the healthcare industry $150 billion each year.

[102] One study found that 65 percent of patients felt transportation assistance would enable them to fill prescriptions as directed after discharge.

[103] The University of Illinois Hospital, part of the University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences System, identified that large portion of the individuals with high rates of emergency department were also chronically homeless, and that these individuals were in the 10th decile for patient cost, with annual per patient expenses ranging from $51,000 to $533,000.

[104] Some health plans have chosen to address some SDOH within their own means by establishing programs that directly deal with a single risk factor.

ACA Medicaid expansion by state: [ 11 ]
Not adopted
Implemented
Life expectancy vs healthcare spending of rich OECD countries. US average of $10,447 in 2018 . [ 14 ] [ 15 ]
Total healthcare cost per person . Public and private spending. US dollars PPP . $6,319 for Canada in 2022. $12,555 for the US in 2022. [ 16 ]
Health spending by country . Percent of GDP ( Gross domestic product ). 11.2% for Canada in 2022. 16.6% for the United States in 2022. [ 16 ]
Health spending per capita, in US$ PPP-adjusted , compared amongst various first world nations
The spring 2010 healthcare reform issue of Ms. magazine
Uninsured Americans, with the numbers shown here from 1987 to 2008, are a major driver for reform efforts.