[2] The album was recorded over a period of several years, in Brooklyn, New York, and Burbank, California, with producers Shahzad Ismaily, Buddy Ross, and Ariel Rechtshaid.

The album includes contributions from Wynonna Judd, Danielle Haim, Joe Russo, the Chapin Sisters, and Charles Burnham.

[5] Michael James Hall of Under the Radar wrote, "Heartmind is an album that demands, then requites, love and attention.

For those willing to dedicate their time to exploring its shadowy riches, it's a gratifying if elusory pleasure.

"[9] Mark Richardson of the Wall Street Journal wrote of the album, "Like so much of his best work, it tackles hard questions and draws on a wide range of music, but it's ultimately accessible and easy to appreciate on first listen", calling it "an arresting collection of songs that tackles pain and uncertainty with humor and grace, from an underrated troubadour who makes it look easy".