Her accomplishments led her to be named to the Hall of Fame for her high school, one of 12 members in the first class of inductees.

[5][6][7] She began her coaching career immediately after graduating from Greensboro as an assistant at Division II Catawba College.

In the first season, she guided the team to a 21–9 record, finishing first in the Peach Belt Conference and earning an invitation to the NCAA Division II postseason tournament.

In Macy's third and final year at Francis Marion, the team again went 27–5, finishing second in the conference and reaching the second round of the postseason NCAA Division II tournament.

On October 17, 2018, Macy resigned amid an internal review based upon a misunderstanding of practice rules to prevent amplifying distraction from an already controversial athletic department.

[13] During the 2019–20 season, Macy served as the head women’s basketball coach at Spartanburg Methodist College.

On September 24, 2020 Macy was named head coach and Assistant Director of Athletics at Greensboro College in North Carolina.

Last season, Coach Macy led the Pride to the regular season USA South Championship, with an 18–0 conference record, 26–3 overall, while also leading the Pride to the tournament championship title, qualifying Greensboro for their first trip to the NCAA Tournament since 2015.

She currently travels around the country educating teams, coaches, and organizations on how to use EQ to become an elite performer.

She is currently hosting a 1-hour weekly Rising Coaches TV series discussing her book, Two Feet Forward: Everyday Lessons in Leadership.

Combined with her EQ Certification, in the spring of 2020, Coach Macy also received aspecialization in Positive Psychology from the University of Pennsylvania.