The Nashville/Henderson team finished with a 39–31 overall record, ending the season 1.5 games behind the first place Evansville Brewers.
In the first season of play in the new league, the Blue Birds finished with a 48–60 record in the final standings.
[1][7][8] The Henderson Blue Birds returned to play in 1904 and again placed fourth in the Kentucky–Illinois–Tennessee League standings.
The Blue Birds finished 19.5 games behind the first place Paducah Indians in the final standings.
On July 18, 1905, the Hens had a record of 29–47 under managers Jake Zimbro and Hary Kubitz when the franchise folded.
The league then halted play on August 17, 1905, due to the Yellow Fever epidemic.
[1] On July 21, 1912, Fred Ostendorf of Henderson pitched a no-hitter against the Cairo Egyptians.
The team placed fourth in the standings under managers Dave Anderson and Ward Snyder.
[17] In their final season of play, the 1916 Henderson Hens were in second place when the Kentucky–Illinois–Tennessee League folded.
The league disbanded August 4, 1916, with a record of 44–30, playing the season under manager Connie Walsh.