Manthei was a three-time all-state performer in soccer while earning the same honor in track twice and basketball once.

[4] During her first year, she earned consensus second-team All American honors and led the nation in assists with 30, the second highest single-season mark in women's college history.

Making its third straight appearance in the NCAA championship game, the Irish lost 0-1 to the North Carolina Tar Heels.

[2] During her senior year, Manthei captained the Fighting Irish, helping her team to their fourth consecutive NCAA tournament.

She was a finalist for the Hermann Trophy and Missouri Athletic Club Player of the Year Award.