"God So Loved" was the band's second Hot Christian Songs top ten single, peaking at No.

Holy Water achieved commercial success in the United States, the album having debuted at No.

[7] "Don't Tread on Me" peaked at number 40 on the Hot Christian Songs Chart.

"[15] CCM Magazine's Ross Cluver gave a favourable review of the album, describing it as "one of the strongest worship projects so far this year.

"[18] Jesus Freak Hideout's Alex Caldwell says in his four star review: "Holy Water is a refreshing album for these troubled times, and a reminder that the author of all things created music in all of its forms.

"[17] In the United States, Holy Water debuted at number four on the Billboard's Top Christian Albums Chart dated August 22, 2020.