[4][5] They won the Division One title in 2004–05, but were denied promotion due to ground grading regulations.

[2] In 2010–11 the club finished bottom of Division One South and were relegated to the Sussex County League again.

YM then started the 2024-25 season in fine form winning 3 of their first 5 games and sitting in 5th place.

However YM the hit a tough run of form winning only 2 of their next 12 games dropping down to 15th place.

YM then sparked controversy as their all time record appearance holder Dean Carden who had been at the club for 25 years resigned from his position as manager citing issues behind the scenes.

In 1929 they moved to Gorings Mead, which backed onto Horsham's Queen Street ground.