[1] The club aims to achieve a balance of success and camaraderie on and off the field as well as encouraging people all of ages and genders to enjoy their rugby.

[5] In 1966, Hunters Hill made a return to Subbies and over the next six years expanded from one senior team to three.

Coached by former the NSW and Wallaby player John Francis, the club achieved immediate success by winning the Division I first grade premiership in 1972 for the Kentwell Cup.

[5] Through the 1970s and 1980s, Hunters Hill had a golden period in Division I, securing Kentwell Cup victories in 1972, 1977–79, 1981, and 1987.

[7] Hunter's Hill undertook a recruitment drive to boost playing members ahead of the Club's centenary in 1992.

A colts team was also formed in 1995, and the club entered and won the NSW Sevens tournament.

[7] In 2016, Hunters Hill won the Subbies 7's Tournament, beating Blacktown 15–5 in the final,[9] before claiming the Barraclough Cup once again as the first grade premiers in Division II.

Hunter's Hill was awarded the Division II Club Champions Reliance Shield.

[11] Hunters Hill has won club championship and premiership titles across multiple competitions since 1919:[7]