I Wish We All Could Win is the debut album from the Christian rock band The Afters.

[2] The website "Soul Purpose" remarked in their review: "The Afters display talent belying their short existence.

A glimpse of the soul is rare indeed [but] the Afters debut effortlessly captures that."

More often than not, critics have approved of the soulful pop rock The Afters deliver on this disc, regardless of its more overt religious themes.

Jesus Freak Hideout gave the album 4½ stars out of 5 commenting that "The Afters' approach to worship is a classy and thoughtful one.