Built as a stagecoach stopover between Trenton and the Jersey Shore in the mid-19th century, the current structure was rebuilt following a fire in 1904.

The Happy Apple was opened in 1972 by the father of its present owners, Buddy Westendorf and wife Donna.

Since the community's addition to the state and national registers of historic places in 1985, portions have suffered from neglect.

Upper Freehold's recent "Master Plan" was supposed to address the preservation of historic structures, rural character, and open space.

Preservation New Jersey[8] believes that preventing the decay of Imlaystown is key to realizing the vision of this plan.