[citation needed] In the 2012 film Underworld: Awakening, Eisley was cast as Eve, the hybrid daughter of Selene and Michael Corvin; Eisley was cast due to her strong resemblance to Selene's actress, Kate Beckinsale.

[citation needed] Eisley starred as Sawa in the 2014 action film Kite, opposite Samuel L.

[7] The same year, she was cast in the title role in the television film adaptation of the V. C. Andrews' book My Sweet Audrina for Lifetime,[8] which aired in 2016.

[9] In 2018, Eisley played the lead role of Maria / Airam in the psychological thriller film Look Away.

[10][11] Author Jessica Brody expressed a desire for Eisley to portray her character Seraphina in the film adaptation of her novel Unremembered.