Green Lantern begins a search for the criminal army when he discovers the town has re-appeared a few miles away, and the felons are looting uthorium from a lab.
Green Lantern saves the tanks and men, then follows the trail to discover Brainwave inside a weird glass box.
Firing his power ring at it, the ray bounces back, knocking Green Lantern off a cliff, apparently to his death.
[5] The second formation appeared in the late 1940s attempting "patriotic crimes" where it was formed by Wizard and consisted of Fiddler, Harlequin, Huntress, Icicle, and Sportsmaster.
They stole national monuments, hoping the American people would vote for the best crime allowing that person to become the leader, and succeeding in erasing the Society's memories after capturing them by the Sportsmaster knocking them out with one of his bombs, but Harlequin turned against them and with Black Canary restored the Justice Society's memories, though a post-hypnotic impulse restores the JSA to their mindless states when they hear fingers snapping, causing them to be recaptured.
[8] Vandal Savage tricks the JSA into aiding a false Camelot while Icicle, Thinker, Wizard, and Brainwave capture Wildcat and the Hourman.
This leads Wayne to summon via Robin's JSA signaller Wonder Woman, Hourman, and Starman to fight the so-called rogue JSA members Power Girl, Hawkman, Flash, Green Lantern, Star Spangled Kid and Dr Fate, during which Power Girl was severely injured(and later recovered) by Wayne's actions.
[12] During what some described as the "anti-costumed-hero mania" (as chronicled in the DC miniseries Legends) in the pages of Infinity, Inc., the Wizard gathered both old comrades (consisting of Brainwave, the Fiddler, Gambler, Harlequin, Per Degaton, Shade, Solomon Grundy, Sportsmaster, Thinker, and Vandal Savage) and new super-criminals (consisting of Hazard, the Icicle II, and the Tigress III) into a new Injustice Society, which he called "Injustice Unlimited".
[14] Johnny Sorrow appears in late 1999 as the leader of the new Injustice Society (consisting of Icicle II, Blackbriar Thorn, Count Vertigo, Geomancer, Killer Wasp, and Tigress III).
Together they storm the headquarters of superhero team Justice Society of America, although JSA member Wildcat defeats them all (destroying Blackbriar Thorn) despite still recovering from a broken arm and the attack initially being launched while he was in the bathtub, with the exception of Sorrow, who uses the diversion to steal an unknown artifact.
[15] Sorrow returns with a larger version of the Injustice Society (having also recruited Black Adam after removing a brain tumour, Shiv, Rival, and the Thinker A.I.)
The soul of the Wizard joined forces with Johnny Sorrow where they gathered a new incarnation of the Injustice Society consisting of the Gentleman Ghost, Icicle II, Rag Doll I, Solomon Grundy, the Thinker A.I., and Tigress III.
They were tasked to steal Prometheus' Cosmic Key from JSA headquarters in order to free the Wizard and Johnny Sorrow.
When it was discovered that Tigress III and Icicle II had started to fall in love with each other, Johnny Sorrow strong-armed them into sticking around.
After Brain Wave unleashes a powerful psychic attack that knocks everyone down, Per Degaton and Vandal Savage prepare to finish off Hawkman and Hawkgirl.
It is led by Scandal Savage and consists of Doctor Elemental, Fog, Gentleman Ghost, Johnny Sorrow (who was impersonating Obsidian), Lady Eve, Red Lantern II, Shadow Thief, Solomon Grundy, and Wotan.
Before Johnny Sorrow can remove his mask upon returning to his true form, Doctor Mid-Nite throws one of her blackout bombs at him and runs.
[27] This formation included the following additional members: These members were recruited after the Wizard was believed dead and both the Fiddler and the Shade were imprisoned: Later recruits included: The Injustice Society resurfaced again in November 2005 in the pages of JSA Classified, composed of: The Injustice Society resurfaced once more, this time in a plot to kidnap Stargirl and to face off against the JSA All Stars.
The team was composed of the following members:[28] The Injustice Society makes a cameo appearance in JSA: The Golden Age #4, consisting of the Fiddler, the Gambler, the Harlequin, and Psycho-Pirate.