[3] Speaking about the song in retrospect, lead singer John O'Callaghan stated: "'Into Your Arms' represents many things for me now on more than just a song-specific level.

It represents the innocence of our band at the time and the wide-eyed optimism we all shared about our musical future.

[5] On April 25, 2019, the group released a vinyl edition of the song with "Everything I Ask For" serving as the B-side for the single.

[6] "Into Your Arms" was written by Kennedy Brock, Pat Kirch, Jared Monaco, Garrett Nickelsen and John O'Callaghan while production was handled by Matt Squire.

[10] James Shotwell of Under the Gun Review stated that the song is, "a heavy ballad with some gorgeous, yet simple piano work.