Its cast also features Olivia Delcán, Nuria Román, Miguel Ángel Furones, Lilian Caro, Tim Bettermann, and Lluís Marqués.

Once in the island, Fer acquaints with sculptor Nuria and her daughter Olivia, who is caught in between her current boyfriend and her ex, a local man.

Pere Vall of Fotogramas rated Isla bonita 4 out of 5 stars, highlighting its pleasant freshness and the play of Delcán and her boyfriends, also pointing out that the film, while flirting with Woody Allen and François Truffaut, still feel very much Colomo's.

[2] Andrea G. Bermejo of Cinemanía rated the "minimal" yet "authentic and fresh" production 3½ stars, highlighting Colomo's onscreen comicity in his own film, in between "Moretti and Woody Allen", and "more of a loser than Louis C.K.

[8] Jordi Batlle Caminal of La Vanguardia deemed the film to be "balsamic, refreshing and airy, as well as spontaneous".