[4] It was a collection of 11 tracks,[1] most of which were cover tunes of country songs from the era such as "Yearning", "Willingly", "Someone I Used to Know" and "My Tears Don't Show".

[4] Jack Greene, Jeannie Seely received positive reviews from music magazines following its original release.

Billboard believed the album would be a strong seller in the country field, finding the other tracks matching the quality of their first single.

[5] Cash Box magazine had a similar finding, stating, "Jack Greene and Jeannie Seely have successfully blended their individual talents and made an album that may well be as big as the hit single it contains.

"[6] Record World gave it four stars and commented that the album had received positive feedback from disc jockeys: "Whoever had the great idea of teaming these two must be beaming these days.