[2] Anibaba was born in Davis, California[3][4] where he attended Davis Senior High School, where in his senior season he was the California Gatorade Soccer Player of the year, and played college soccer at Santa Clara University for the first three years of his college career.

In 2009, Anibaba captained the Broncos, who were selected for the National Soccer Coaches Association of America (NSCAA) All-West Region team.

[5] Anibaba made twelve appearances for USL Premier Development League club Carolina Dynamo during their 2010 season.

[9] Anibaba would go on to tally two more goals in the 2011 season finale, heading home two strikes in the space of 19 minutes in a 3–2 win vs. Columbus Crew on October 22, 2011.

[21] On Monday, February 13, 2023, Anibaba announced his retirement from professional soccer, after which he was named the first-ever club ambassador for Nashville SC.