The lyrics of "James" narrate a heartfelt conversation between two friends who chose different paths in life, reflecting on the choices they've made and the pressures of societal and familial expectations.
The lyrics express admiration for James' dedication and perseverance, noting that he has "carried the weight of family pride" and "lived up to expectations."
There’s a recurring theme of internal conflict, questioning whether James has the freedom to pursue his authentic self or if he's conforming to what others envision for him.
The narrator’s questioning tone implies concern that James may never reach his full potential—symbolized as writing his "masterpiece"—if he continues on a path that may not truly fulfill him.
It's certainly judgmental as hell but that soprano sax solo is a treat and Joel's Wurlitzer electric piano (or Fender Rhodes?)