[2] It is the band's biggest commercial success, having been certified platinum in the United States by the RIAA; it is their first and only single to receive a certification award.

"Jamie All Over" was originally written and released by A Kid Named Chicago, before they merged with Defining Moment to form Mayday Parade.

[3] The track was written by Jason Lancaster, Derek Sanders, Jeremy Lenzo, Alex Garcia, Jake Bundrick and Brooks Betts while production was handled by Zack Odom and Kenneth Mount.

"[9] Sputnikmusic remarked, "'Jamie All Over''s passionate cries merge so well with the broken guitar riffs and energetic drumming you've heard a million times before, but it's just better.

[13] The video showcases the group "stack their chips high in the great tradition of glossy Vegas," in a "James Bond Style Casino.