The first settlers in the county were Andrew Moore and his family, who arrived in 1810, but he and one of his sons were killed by Indians,[1]: 122 and his wife and her remaining children left and settled in Equality.
[1]: 136 A few individuals wished for a different location, but no significant dissension ever arose,[2]: 33 and the commissioners chose "Mount Vernon" as the name of the new town, due to their reverence for George Washington.
[2]: 37 At their first meeting, the county commissioners' court ordered the construction of a courthouse, to be a simple log building 18 by 20 feet (5.5 m × 6.1 m) with a single door and window, and to be completed by September 1819.
The situation changed completely on a calm, quiet night in 1839; the first people stirring in the morning discovered that the courthouse had partially collapsed, leaving a hole on one side large enough to drive a wagon through, and the remains were pulled down with ropes.
Their hands having been forced, the commissioners began making arrangements for a replacement,[1]: 306 a square brick building 40 feet (12 m) on each side with a cupola atop the roof.