They are currently members of the Combined Counties League Premier Division South and play at Springfield Stadium.

In 2015 the Jersey Football Association applied to UEFA and FIFA to allow them to play other teams, in a similar arrangement to Gibraltar.

In November 2018, The Football Association approved the club's bid to join Division One of the Combined Counties League for the 2019–20 season.

Freeman was manager at St Peter from February 2015 and took on the Jersey Bulls role from the end of the 2018–19 season.

[8] The first eight fixtures of the league were announced by the Combined Counties Football League on 5 June to allow clubs preparation in booking transport to or from Jersey, with Ash United being the first team to visit Jersey and Deportivo Galicia being the first away fixture.

[18] On 7 March 2020, Forward Lorne Bickley signed a short-term contract with National League side Hartlepool United.

[22] On 30 March 2020, Jersey Bulls were one of sixty-six non-league clubs who sent an open letter to the Football Association requesting that they reconsider their decision.

On 5 September, Jersey Bulls began their second season in Division One away to Bedford & Feltham with a 4–1 victory.

[24] The Bulls would subsequently defeat British Airways 2–0, Fleet Spurs 1-0 and Ash United 3–2, all away from home.

In April 2020, The Bulls launched a competition to choose the third kit and the winning designed was announced on 1 May 2020 on their social media as a dark blue shirt with pink trim, based on the colours of their second biggest sponsor, Butterfield Bank.