Wagner has also had guest roles on a variety of television series, including Quintuplets and Bones.

[10][11] In March 2008, Wagner was announced as the on-field host for the ABC game show Wipeout, which premiered June 24, 2008.

[14] In late August 2012, it was announced that Wagner would return as the co-host of Wipeout for its sixth season,[15] a role she continued throughout the rest of the series' run.

In 2013, Wagner appeared on Rhett and Link's third episode of their YouTube series The Mythical Show;[16] this was in response to an episode of their talk show Good Mythical Morning, where they mentioned they had gone to college with a girl who had caught their interest, but never had the courage to talk to, who was revealed to be Wagner.

[23] In 2023, Wagner appeared as a main cast member, playing CIA operative Bobby, in the first season of Taylor Sheridan's Special Ops: Lioness series.

[24] In April 2017, Wagner married Canadian former minor league (including AHL, CHL) ice hockey player[25] David Lemanowicz, after they had announced their engagement earlier in 2016.