[2] Almgill played the role of Yvonne in the 2018 musical version of The Proclaimers' Sunshine on Leith, joining Steven Miller and Paul-James Corrigan.
[3] In 2019, Almgill joined the Royal Exchange production of West Side Story in the role of Anita, with Maria played by Gabriela Garcia and Tony by Andy Coxon.
The cast included Miriam Teak-Lee as Juliet, Jordan Luke Gage as Romeo, David Bedella as Lance, Cassidy Janson as Anne Hathaway, Oliver Tompsett as Shakespeare, Melanie La Barrie as the Nurse, Arun Blair-Mangat as May, Tim Mahendran as Francois and Almgill as Lady Capulet.
[7] Cast included Dan Partridge as Danny, Olivia Moore as Sandy with Peter Andre and Jason Donovan alternating in the role of Teen Angel.
[8] In April 2024, casting for the Curve/Sadler's Wells production of A Chorus Line was announced, with Adam Cooper in the role of Zach, Carly Mercedes Dyer as Cassie and Almgill as Diana.