The story is similar to those of Robin Hood, except that the merchant does not join the band of thieves.
The merchant says he cannot go by Barnisdale or Coventry, fearing Jock will rob him.
If six bowmen and Jock fight him and are able to get him one foot from his pack, he will give it to them.
Refusing to join the "robber-band," the merchant parts, promising to call Jock a thief if they ever meet again.
Unlike Robin, Jock's summoning his men with his horn does not end the fray, and the stranger rejects his invitation.