[1] Weatherby made his first-class debut for RS Lucas' XI during the team's tour of the West Indies in early 1895.
He made his debut against Barbados, and played seven further first-class matches on tour, the last coming against Jamaica.
[4] In England, Weatherby made his debut for Buckinghamshire in the 1896 Minor Counties Championship against Oxfordshire.
[5] Later, when in the British Raj, Weatherby played first-class cricket for the Europeans, twice against the Parsees in 1901 and again against the same opposition in a single match in 1903.
His brothers Charles and Francis played first-class cricket, as did his nephew John Atkinson-Clark.