Born in Scotland, he earned one cap for the United States national team.
[1] In 1921, he moved to the U.S. club Robins Dry Dock of the National Association Football League (NAFBL).
However, before folding, Todd went to the 1922 National Challenge Cup final where it fell, 3–2 to St. Louis Scullin Steel.
[3] McGuire then moved to the New Bedford Whalers for the 1924–1925 season before closing out his career with Brooklyn Wanderers in 1925–1926.
McGuire earned one cap with the U.S. national team in a 6–1 win over Canada on November 8, 1925.