McNicholl was a stand-out performer in the 2012 National Provincial Championship, heading the Top tryscorers list with 10, three ahead of his nearest rival.

His consistent ability to cross the line drew interest from new Blues coach John Kirwan, but McNicholl, who played his club rugby for Sydenham in the Christchurch Metro competition, opted to commit to the Crusaders.

[3] At the age of 29 he made his debut for Wales in the starting line up for the uncapped international against the Barbarians on 30 November 2019.

[5] He made his capped debut for Wales 1 February 2020 in the starting lineup for the Six Nations 42–0 win against Italy.

[6] This biographical article relating to New Zealand rugby union, about a person born in the 1990s, is a stub.