[1] He earned All-Pac 5 League honors as a junior and senior quarterback, while also playing defensive back for the Warriors.
[4] Despite playing only two seasons at Cal Poly, Dally's combined 75 passing and rushing touchdowns totaled a school career record, which would later be matched by Chris Brown.
Following the 2008 regular season, Dally was selected to the All-Great West Conference First Team[7] and received two write-in votes for seven total points in the balloting for the Walter Payton Award.
For the 2012-2013 seasons, Dally signed with the Danube Dragons of the Austrian Football League in February 2012,[9] and played with the club through 2013.
He also quarterbacked Milano to a repeat title in 2015, again earning the co-MVP honor as the Seamen defeated the Parma Panthers 24–14 in the XXXV edition of the game, held at Stadio Vigorelli.