[9] On January 4, 2019, Love released a statement on his Instagram to officially announce his decision to forgo his senior season at Notre Dame to enter the 2019 NFL Draft.

[17][18] Head coach Pat Shurmur named Love the third free safety on the depth chart to begin the regular season, behind starter Antoine Bethea and backup Sean Chandler.

[22] On January 8, 2020, the New York Giants announced the hiring of former New England Patriots' special teams coordinator Joe Judge as their new head coach.

[24] Defensive coordinator Patrick Graham named Love and Jabrill Peppers the starting safety duo to begin the regular season.

[29] On January 28, 2022, the New York Giants hired Buffalo Bills' offensive coordinator Brian Daboll as their new head coach after Joe Judge was terminated after a 14–3 record.

[30] Following the departures of Jabril Peppers and Logan Ryan, defensive coordinator Don Martindale held a competition between Love, Xavier McKinney, Jason Pinnock, and Tony Jefferson to determine the starting safeties.

He was inactive as a healthy scratch for a Week 18 loss to the Green Bay Packers as Brian Daboll chose to rest his starters.

On January 15, 2023, Love started in his first career playoff appearance and made four combined tackles (two solo) during a 31–24 victory at the Minnesota Vikings in the NFC Wild Card Game.

[34][15] During training camp, he competed against Jerrick Reed and Coby Bryant to be the starting strong safety as Jamal Adams was still recovering from his injury.

Prior to Week 4, Love was demoted to the primary backup safety and nickelback after Jamal Adams returned to takeover his starting role.

[35] In Week 8 of the 2023 season against the Cleveland Browns, Love intercepted a pass thrown by P. J. Walker that led to the game-winning touchdown as the Seahawks won 24–20.

[39] On January 31, 2024, the Seattle Seahawks hired Baltimore Ravens' defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald as their head coach to replace Pete Carroll.

Defensive coordinator Aden Durde retained Love as a starter with the other role being competed for by Rayshawn Jenkins, K'Von Wallace, and Coby Bryant.

[41] Head coach Mike Macdonald named Love the starting free safety to begin the season, alongside Rayshawn Jenkins.

[43][15] On September 8, 2024, Love started in the Seattle Seahawks' home-opener against the Denver Broncos and collected a season-high 12 combined tackles (ten solo), broke up a pass, forced a fumble, and had the first career interception thrown by rookie Bo Nix to wide receiver Courtland Sutton during a 26–20 victory.