[3] The album features seven of Tillis' favorite Christmas songs, along with three new compositions.

The album also features background vocals from Tillis' nieces and nephews.

About.com gave the album five stars, stating that "Tillis has a voice like no other and she can draw you into the mood with very little effort.

"[5] The North County Times gave the album an A− rating, saying that "Tillis' warm yet feathery voice lends new charm to old favorites.

"[6] The Omaha World-Herald rated the album B+, praising the new tracks as being "especially to-die-for.