In 1996, Todd Terry featuring Martha Wash & Jocelyn Brown's version also reached number one on the US Billboard Hot Dance Club Play chart.
"[5]Upon the release, Larry Flick from Billboard wrote that here, "three titans of dance music gather for a positively electric rendition of Musique's disco-era chestnut."
"[6] William Stevenson from Entertainment Weekly stated that "Keep On Jumpin'" was "nearly as catchy as the "Macarena"" and added that "this confection is certainly bouncy enough to become a staple of aerobics classes.
[8] Music Week editor Alan Jones commented, "Terry opts for vocal attack, pairing two of the most popular and enduring disco divas — Martha Wash and Jocelyn Brown — with impressive results.
"[9] Dave Fowler from Muzik gave it four and a half out of five, describing the song as a "oh-so-perfectly produced package of classic house" that "is sure to keep it pumpin' for lovers of deep Americana on both sides of the pond.
Pan-European magazine Music & Media wrote, "The Lisa Marie Experience Going back to Lipps Inc's 'Funky Town' but without that unforgettable rhythm guitar, that's the feeling you get from this updated "disco-inferno" with cheeky girls and wild strings.
"[23] A reviewer from Music Week rated the song four out of five, adding, "Massive on the club scene, this bubbling house anthem is predicted to bump and hustle its way to chart success, morphing from the underground track to household staple a la Josh Wink.
"[24] Andy Beevers from the magazine's RM Dance Update gave it five out of five, noting that "their pumping house intro gives way to a guitar breakdown before the full-on disco pressure takes hold with Chris Wiltshire's infectious vocals vying for attention with those classic strings stabs.