Although the town of Keith is relatively small, the club have produced a few notable players such as Hamish French and former Scotland captain, Colin Hendry.

In a 1995–96 Scottish Cup match at Pittodrie Stadium in Aberdeen, the club suffered a 10–1 defeat at the hands of Rangers.

Kynoch Park hosted its first Scottish Cup game was in 1928, with Keith recording a 5–2 win against Dalbeattie Star.

They went on to lose 6–1 in the second round against Scottish Cup holders Celtic in front of a record crowd of 5,820.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.