A tough defender with the Fighting Irish, Lindsey backstopped the team to a runners-up finish in the 1999 NCAA Division I Women's Soccer Championship.
[6] Lindsey's first appearance on the United States women's national soccer team was on January 7, 2000, in an 8–1 win over Czech Republic in Melbourne, Australia.
[7][8] She collected a total of four caps over the following two years,[9] but was not included in the US squads for the 2000 Sydney Olympics, or the 2003 FIFA Women's World Cup.
In 2009, she took the lead of Sky Blue FC, part of the newly formed Women's Professional Soccer League after Head Coach Ian Sawyers was terminated.
Lindsay resigned with two weeks left in the regular season without explanation and Sky Blue FC went on to win the Championship.